I'm Josh. I watch a lot of films and play a lot of games set in the past, and I keep pausing them to look things up. This is where I write up what I find: what really happened, what got made up, and where historians still disagree.

I'm not a historian, so every post lists its sources and I fix mistakes in the open. Most posts also have a video on the YouTube channel.

Latest

ACCURACY · BEYOND THE MARGIN · OUT OF TEN ·3

Gladiator II: how accurate is it?

The real people are in the right era, but almost everything they do on screen is made up. Great spectacle, shaky history.

Read the full post

Sections

  • Films 1 post

    Films set in the past, checked against the sources.

  • TV coming soon

    Period dramas and historical series, checked against the sources.

  • Games coming soon

    Games set in the past, and how close they get to the real thing.

  • Deep dives coming soon

    Longer pieces on history I think more people should know about.